Rochester Mayor Lovely Warren submits resignation letter after accepting plea deal

Regional News

Plea deal resolves other charges mayor was facing in unrelated case

ROCHESTER, N.Y. (WROC) — Rochester Mayor Lovely Warren will resign after accepting the terms of a plea deal Monday in court. Her resignation will be effective December 1.

The mayor’s trial was scheduled to begin Monday for charges over alleged campaign finance violations that date back to her 2017 re-election campaign.

Warren and two assistants —Albert Jones Jr. and Rosiland Brooks-Harris— were accused of using a PAC to get around donation limits during her 2017 campaign. They each faced two charges; scheme to defraud in the first degree, and violation of election law — both of which are class E felonies.

One of the attorneys in the courtroom told News 8 Monday morning that negotiations on the table would reduce the mayor’s felony charges to misdemeanor charges, which means the mayor’s law license would not be impacted. The deal, however, would require Warren to resign.

Several hours later, the mayor ultimately accepted those terms. Jones Jr. and Brooks Harris also pleaded guilty Monday.

Terms of the plea will also resolve another set of criminal charges the mayor is currently facing. Warren and her estranged husband, Timothy Granison, were each handed three different charges after a pistol and rifle were found in their home where their daughter was left alone in May.

The mayor is serving the remainder of what is presumptively her last term in office. She was defeated handedly by current City Councilmember Malik Evans in this year’s June Democratic primary and she is not on the November ballot.

Warren was sworn in to the office in January 2014, and was re-elected in 2017. She was running for re-election this year, set to face off against City Councilmember Malik Evans in a Democratic primary on June 22. Evans will be sworn into office in the new year. Deputy Mayor James Smith will become acting mayor upon Warren’s effective resignation date on December 1.

The mayor said, on advice from her counsel, that she would refrain from commenting on the guilty plea Monday and she exited the courtroom without addressing reporters.

Warren’s attorney, Joe Damelio, says there was no missing money in this case, just a mistake as to where money was reported to be deposited.

“There was no scheme here, there was no fraud here, no one is missing any money,” Damelio said. “There was no scheme here, there was no fraud here. There was no attempt to defraud anyone. Everything was out in the open. Even the Political Action Committee — think about it: If you’re going to scam somebody and there’s a tool to use, an independent expenditure or a Political Action Community are you going to put it in your own name? Of course not; that was the mistake that they made.”

A formal resignation letter was submitted to City Council leadership Monday night:

Prior to being mayor, Warren served on Rochester City Council from 2007 through 2013, and was elected as Council President in 2010, becoming the youngest person to hold that position in the Council’s history.

Warren was the first woman to become Rochester mayor, and the city’s youngest mayor in modern times. She was born and raised in the city’s 19th Ward Neighborhood.

Activists and protesters called for Warren’s resignation after details regarding Daniel Prude’s death came to light.

The circumstances of Prude’s death were not made public until September of 2020, six months after it happened. Police body camera footage that was eventually released to the public, and the delay between then and Prude’s death, sparked protests in Rochester and beyond.

Public disagreements between Rochester Mayor Lovely Warren and then-Police Chief La’Ron Singletary highlighted the controversies brought up by city hall’s handling of the case. That culminated in a nearly nine-hour deposition in which Singletary disputed the mayor’s claims regarding Prude’s death and the six-month delay between when it happened and when the public was notified.

An independent City Council investigation concluded that key City of Rochester officials “knowingly suppressed” information about Prude’s death, and said the ultimate decision to not disclose the death of Prude to the public was that of Mayor Lovely Warren, but it fell short of saying she was solely responsible.

Monroe County Legislator Rachel Barnhart (D-21), who lost to Warren in the 2017 mayoral primary, was one of the first to raise concerns over Warren’s campaign spending. Barnhart issued the following statement Monday:

“Our democracy depends on fair elections. Both of Lovely Warren’s opponents raised this issue in 2017 and were ignored. Public corruption cannot be tolerated, and we have a lot of work to do at the state and local level to ensure ethical conduct. For starters, we need a New York State Board of Elections that enforces the law. I am glad to see a resolution that includes accountability.”


Local leaders on Mayor Warren’s resignation

Check back with News 8 WROC as we will continue to update this developing story.

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

If you have a news tip or a correction to the story you can email it to us through this link. If you would like to send a comment to the author of the story, you can find their email on our Meet the Team page.

Trending Now